WASHINGTON, D.C. — Peter Navarro, now senior counselor for trade and manufacturing in the Trump administration, has asked the Supreme Court to throw out his 2023 convictions for contempt of Congress, a case that could make such prosecutions harder to win.
Navarro was found guilty on two counts after he refused to give testimony and documents to the House committee that investigated the Jan. 6, 2021, Capitol attack, saying executive privilege barred him. He served four months in federal prison. A federal appeals court in Washington later upheld the verdict, holding that a person who defies a subpoena breaks the law even when he wrongly believed his refusal was lawful.
His petition, filed last month, argues that the contempt statute, 2 U.S.C. Section 192, requires proof that a defendant acted willfully, meaning he knew he was breaking the law. His lawyers point to a 1933 Supreme Court decision that weighed a taxpayer’s sincere but mistaken constitutional belief in judging willfulness.
The Article III Project, a conservative legal group, filed a friend-of-the-court brief backing the petition. The group argues the appeals ruling exposes executive officials to prison for good-faith privilege decisions and upsets long-standing negotiation between Congress and the executive branch.
In April, the Supreme Court vacated the appeals ruling against former White House strategist Steve Bannon in a similar contempt case after the Justice Department moved to dismiss his indictment. The justices have not said whether they will hear the Navarro case.
Section: More Birmingham AL politics news
Filed under: Birmingham AL Politics News