Birmingham, Alabama, October 25, 2025
News Summary
The Alabama Supreme Court has upheld the dismissal of a lawsuit filed by the City of Birmingham against Jefferson County Sheriff Mark Pettway regarding inmate housing. The city argued that Pettway was obligated to accept inmates from Birmingham, yet the court affirmed that without a warrant, the sheriff is not required to house these individuals. This ruling sheds light on the complexities of inmate management amidst ongoing issues at the Birmingham Jail, highlighting a need for further dialogue between local authorities.
Birmingham, Alabama —
The Alabama Supreme Court has upheld the dismissal of a lawsuit brought by the City of Birmingham against Jefferson County Sheriff Mark Pettway regarding the housing of inmates. The ruling clarifies the legal standing of the sheriff concerning the city’s incarcerated individuals under specific circumstances.
The lawsuit, initiated in February 2024, focused on the county’s refusal to house inmates from Birmingham, with the City claiming that Pettway was legally required to accept these inmates. This legal controversy gained traction amid deteriorating conditions at the Birmingham Jail, prompting the city to seek enforcement of prior agreements.
Prior to the lawsuit, Birmingham and Jefferson County had established a memorandum of understanding (MOU) that facilitated the housing of city inmates within the county jail. However, disputes emerged over the financial obligations of the City in terms of the payments for housing these inmates, resulting in complications that eventually led to the termination of the MOU.
The Jefferson County Commission addressed the issue by asserting it was not responsible for ameliorating the conditions at the Birmingham Jail, further complicating the dynamics between the two governmental entities. Sheriff Pettway contended that he was not legally obliged to accept arrestees unless they had valid warrants, a position that fueled the ongoing legal battle.
In a preliminary ruling, a trial court dismissed the lawsuit for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction, describing it as justiciably unripe, leading the City to appeal to the Alabama Supreme Court. The Supreme Court’s decision, released on a Friday, characterized the trial court’s dismissal as mistaken, noting the legal grounds for a valid complaint did exist.
Despite recognizing the procedural error from the lower court, the Supreme Court affirmed that Sheriff Pettway is not legally mandated to accept inmates from the City without a warrant. The court specified that there is no statute requiring him to accept arrestees without proper warrant documentation and highlighted that individuals arrested by the City for state law violations can remain in the City jail until a warrant is issued.
This ruling sheds light on the responsibilities of law enforcement agencies and local governments concerning inmate housing, particularly in cases where disputes arise over accessibility and legal obligations. Given the backdrop of deteriorating conditions at the Birmingham Jail, continued dialogue between the City of Birmingham and Jefferson County may be necessary to tackle the challenges facing local jail facilities.
Background
Birmingham’s challenges with inmate housing have escalated in recent years, notably due to rising inmate populations and inadequate facilities. The earlier MOU reflected an attempt by both entities to address these issues collaboratively, but the termination of this agreement has left the City scrambling for options to manage its inmates.
The Supreme Court’s ruling plays a pivotal role in defining the legal landscape governing such disputes between municipalities and county law enforcement, thus impacting future negotiations about inmate housing agreements in Alabama.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the ruling of the Alabama Supreme Court regarding the lawsuit from Birmingham?
The Alabama Supreme Court affirmed the dismissal of a lawsuit by the City of Birmingham against Jefferson County Sheriff Mark Pettway over the county’s refusal to house Birmingham inmates.
When was the lawsuit filed by the City of Birmingham?
The City filed a complaint in February 2024, claiming Pettway was legally required to accept inmates.
What was the basis for the city’s complaint?
The lawsuit concerned the county’s refusal to house Birmingham inmates, amid deteriorating conditions at the Birmingham Jail.
What was the outcome of the appeal to the Alabama Supreme Court?
The Supreme Court concluded the trial court erred in dismissing the City’s complaint for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction but found that Pettway is not required by law to accept inmates without a warrant.
Key Features of the Ruling
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Lawsuit Origin | City of Birmingham filed a complaint in February 2024. |
| Key Figure | Jefferson County Sheriff Mark Pettway. |
| Legal Controversy | Refusal to house Birmingham inmates. |
| MOU Status | Terminated due to payment disputes. |
| Supreme Court Findings | No law requires acceptance of arrestees without a warrant. |
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Deputy Faces Assault Charges Following Multi-Vehicle Crash
Deputy Charged After Multi-Vehicle Crash in Birmingham
22-Year-Old Charged with Murder in Birmingham Shooting
Cheerleader in Critical Condition Following Jefferson County Shooting
Damien McDaniel Charged in Connection with 14 Murders
Keena Deon Creer Indicted for Capital Murder in Birmingham
Suspect Arrested in Series of Car Break-Ins in Birmingham
Significant Developments in Alabama
Birmingham Sets Stage for Key Runoff Elections
Cancellation of ‘Our Issues: Birmingham’ Raises Concerns
Additional Resources
- 1819 News: Alabama Supreme Court Sides with Jefferson County Sheriff
- AL.com: Birmingham City Jail Inmate Dies at Hospital
- Encyclopedia Britannica: The Letter from the Birmingham Jail
- WSFA: Elmore County Woman Charged After Incident
- AL.com: Birmingham City Jail Inmate Found Dead in Cell
Author: STAFF HERE BIRMINGHAM WRITER
The BIRMINGHAM STAFF WRITER represents the experienced team at HEREBirmingham.com, your go-to source for actionable local news and information in Birmingham, Jefferson County, and beyond. Specializing in "news you can use," we cover essential topics like product reviews for personal and business needs, local business directories, politics, real estate trends, neighborhood insights, and state news affecting the area—with deep expertise drawn from years of dedicated reporting and strong community input, including local press releases and business updates. We deliver top reporting on high-value events such as the Sidewalk Film Festival, Sloss Music & Arts Festival, Magic City Classic, and civil rights commemorations. Our coverage extends to key organizations like the Birmingham Business Alliance and the Birmingham Civil Rights Institute, plus leading businesses in healthcare, finance, and manufacturing that power the local economy such as UAB Medicine, Regions Bank, and Encompass Health. As part of the broader HERE network, including HEREHuntsville.com, we provide comprehensive, credible insights into Alabama's dynamic landscape.
